By Lee Haye-ah
WASHINGTON, Oct. 10 (Yonhap) -- The United States must not repeat the failure of past denuclearization negotiations with North Korea by offering premature sanctions relief, former U.S. National Security Adviser H.R. McMaster said Thursday.
"That's the definition of insanity, if we do that again," McMaster, who served under President Donald Trump until April 2018, said during a discussion at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies.
His comments come after working-level denuclearization talks between the U.S. and the North broke down again in Sweden last weekend.
North Korea accused the U.S. of failing to come up with a new proposal acceptable to Pyongyang, while Washington said it brought "creative ideas" and had "good" discussions with the North.
"I don't think it hurts to ... have another summit," McMaster said, alluding to what would be a fourth meeting between Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong-un. "In fact, I think the summits were beneficial in a certain way because in the past, the way that they've been approached before was all bottom-up, and there are just too many opportunities for spoiling."
"If there was going to be a breakthrough," he added, "it would be with an unconventional president with really, still to some degree, an unknown quantity in Kim Jong-un."
The U.S. and North Korea have had on-again, off-again negotiations for decades to try to dismantle the regime's nuclear weapons and ballistic missile programs in exchange for economic and political concessions.
The latest effort under Trump and Kim has stalled as North Korea has demanded sanctions relief and security guarantees in parallel with its denuclearization steps. Meanwhile, the U.S. has demanded the North take significant denuclearization measures first.
McMaster said there is a recognition in the U.S. that it cannot repeat the mistakes of the past by allowing North Korea's "provocation cycle" -- an apparent reference to its latest missile tests -- to result in premature sanctions relief based on an empty promise of negotiations with no meaningful progress toward denuclearization.
"And then, of course, what happens next? Long drawn-out negotiations, during which the North Koreans try to extort more money and payoffs from us," he said. "And then ultimately what do you get? You get a weak agreement that locks in the status quo as the new normal. And then North Korea breaks that agreement right away."
S. Korea's decision for 'independent' naval ops in Hormuz Strait seeks delicate balance between U.S., Iran
Tensions over prosecution reform deepen after reshuffle of senior prosecutors
U.S.-N.K. nuke deadlock may continue in H1 with no signs of budging: experts
Political parties gear up for April 15 elections, with 100-day countdown set to begin
Tensions rise to perilous point in U.S.-NK nuke diplomacy