Go to Contents Go to Navigation

(LEAD) Court rules in favor of singer banned from visiting S. Korea

K-pop 16:36 November 15, 2019

(ATTN: UPDATES with details on ruling, foreign ministry's response in paras 4-12)
By Lee Minji

SEOUL, Nov. 15 (Yonhap) -- An appeals court on Friday reversed its earlier decision and ruled in favor of a Korean-American singer who was banned from entering South Korea in a move that may allow him to finally visit the country for the first time in 17 years.

Steve Yoo, better known as Yoo Seung-jun here, had been banned from entering the country since 2002, when he became the subject of public outcry after giving up his South Korean citizenship, which critics claimed was aimed at dodging military service.

Following botched attempts to enter the country, he filed a lawsuit against the South Korean consulate general in Los Angeles in October 2015 for refusing to grant him a visa. Yoo reportedly applied for an F-4 visa, which is usually issued to Koreans living overseas.

This file photo shows Korean-American singer Steve Yoo. (Yonhap)

The latest ruling marks a turnaround from previous court decisions that deemed the refusal appropriate.

The Seoul administrative court ruled in September 2016 that the singer's return and resumption of activities here could "demoralize soldiers who are devoting themselves to serving the country and provoke youths into evading conscription."

The Seoul High Court upheld the decision in February 2017. However, the Supreme Court in July ordered the appeals court to revisit the ruling, saying it violated due administrative procedure and denying a visa application based on a past entry ban is wrong.

Yoo's lawyers, meanwhile, have claimed it is far-fetched to assume Yoo intended to dodge conscription based on the citizenship renouncement. They've also argued that the de-facto 17-year ban is excessive and violates the constitutional principle of fairness.

Despite the favorable ruling, Yoo's visit to the country is unlikely to be smooth.

The foreign ministry issued a statement saying it will again appeal to the Supreme Court and "closely cooperate with the Justice Ministry, Military Manpower Administration and relevant ministries" in the process.

Negative public sentiment is another stumbling block.

In August, nearly 260,000 people signed a petition in less than a month asking the government to ban Yoo from visiting, saying "(the Supreme Court ruling) is not in line with fairness and evokes a sense of shame."

A nationwide poll of 501 adults conducted by Realmeter in July also showed only 23.3 percent of respondents thought the ban should be lifted since a long time has passed.

Yoo, 43, had been a mega-hit singer until the citizenship issue sparked public fury in a country where mandatory military service is a sensitive issue.

By law, all able-bodied men have to serve in the armed forces for around two years before the age of 38.


Send Feedback
How can we improve?
Thanks for your feedback!