Go to Contents Go to Navigation

(LEAD) Harvard professor Ramseyer to revise paper on 1923 massacre of Koreans in Japan: Cambridge handbook editor

All News 22:28 February 20, 2021

(ATTN: ADDS more info in paras 3, 8-10)
By Song Sang-ho

SEOUL, Feb. 20 (Yonhap) -- A Harvard professor, criticized for his depiction of victims of Japan's wartime sexual slavery as prostitutes, will "significantly" revise another controversial paper on the 1923 massacre of Koreans in Japan, a co-editor of an academic handbook said Saturday.

In an email interview with Yonhap News Agency, Alon Harel, the co-editor of the Cambridge Handbook of Privatization -- expected to be published in August -- called the disputed content of the paper by J. Mark Ramseyer a "very regrettable mistake" and stressed that it will not appear in its original form.

Harel also noted that Ramseyer removed his controversial paper from the Social Science Research Network (SSRN), a repository for scholary papers, after Harel and his fellows asked him to do so.

"It was evidently an innocent and very regrettable mistake on our part," Harel said in response to a question about his views on Ramseyer's paper, entitled "Privatizing Police: Japanese Police, The Korean Massacre, And Private Security Firms."

"I assure you that the paper will not appear in its original form in the collection ... Ramseyer wrote to us that he read our comments (that were detailed and very critical) and will revise significantly the paper in accordance with these comments," he added.

In the paper, Ramseyer of Harvard Law School, citing rumors, depicted Koreans at the time of the post-earthquake chaos around Tokyo in 1923 as "gangs" that "torched buildings, planted bombs, poisoned water supplies" and murdered and raped people.

He also cast doubts over the estimated number of Koreans killed in the massacre, which historians put at around 6,000.

Harel said that the comments he delivered to Ramseyer for revision include those about the testimony regarding alleged violence relating to Koreans, much of which he said is "merely a hearsay from Japanese sources."

The professor refused to elaborate.

"There is much more there but I think the best is to wait for the next draft and see," he said.

Harel also said that while he was fully aware about the atrocities against Koreans during World War II, he and his co-editor were not familiar with historical events before the war during Japan's 1910-45 occupation of the Korean Peninsula.

"We assumed that Professor Ramseyer knows the history better than us. In the meantime, we have learnt a lot about the events and we sent a list of detailed comments on the paper that were written by professional historians and lawyers," he said.

But Harel emphasized that once they learned about detailed historical events that happened to Korean victims, "we took immediate action to repair the damage as much as possible."

"Avihay and I genuinely regret that a misguided description of the history can be found now in the SSRN (and that we are associated with it), but I assure you that the mistake will not be repeated in the forthcoming volume," he said, referring to his co-editor, Avihay Dorfman of Tel Aviv University Law School.

This photo, captured from the YouTube account of Harvard Law School, shows Professor J. Mark Ramseyer. (PHOTO NOT FOR SALE) (Yonhap)


Send Feedback
How can we improve?
Thanks for your feedback!