Anti-DUI law subjecting repeat offense to aggravated punishment ruled unconstitutional
SEOUL, Nov. 25 (Yonhap) -- The Constitutional Court on Thursday ruled against a law that calls for aggravated punishment for repeat drunk drivers because multiple violations are defined as repeat offences no matter how far apart in time they are.
The court delivered the non-constitutional decision against the country's revised Road Traffic Act, dubbed the Yoon Chang-ho Act, named after a victim of a high-profile DUI case.
The revision of the law in 2018 drew a public backlash for its controversial clause subjecting repeat offenders to aggravated penalties of up to five years behind bars or a fine of up to 20 million won (US$16,800).
Seven of the nine constitutional judges ruled against the law on grounds that its vague definition of repeat offences runs against the constitutional principles of having to be definite and not excessive in delivering criminal penalties.
The court stressed that it is hardly reasonable for the law to label a repeat drunk driving offender with a 10-year interval between the two offences as a serious risk to the lives of the community.
Under the current law, DUI offenders of different degrees also have the risk of being punished invariably heavily just because they are repeat offenders, the court said, stressing that the act is in breach of the principal of proportion between responsibility and punishment.
"Heavy punishment on repeated drunk driving could correspond to the sentiment of the general public, but it could foster insensibility toward heavy punishments, possibly tarnishing the authority of law and debilitating the legal order," the court added.
pbr@yna.co.kr
(END)
-
(News Focus) Samsung's Lee expected to solidify leadership, step up biz activities after receiving pardon
-
S. Korea expresses deep regret over Japanese PM's offering to war shrine
-
(LEAD) Yoon pledges to improve ties with Japan, offers economic aid in exchange for N.K. denuclearization
-
(LEAD) Bill Gates calls for S. Korea to play leading role in global health cooperation
-
(LEAD) Candidacy merger off table in DP leadership race
-
(2nd LD) Samsung heir Lee granted special presidential pardon
-
(News Focus) Samsung's Lee expected to solidify leadership, step up biz activities after receiving pardon
-
(LEAD) Yoon pledges to improve ties with Japan, offers economic aid in exchange for N.K. denuclearization
-
(3rd LD) THAAD issue not subject to negotiation: presidential office
-
Today in Korean history
-
(LEAD) N. Korea fires two cruise missiles toward Yellow Sea: S. Korean official
-
N. Korea fires two cruise missiles missile toward Yellow Sea: S. Korean official
-
(LEAD) S. Korea's new COVID-19 cases soar to 4-month high of over 180,000
-
(3rd LD) Yoon offers to carry out aid projects as long as N.K. shows denuclearization commitment
-
Yoon says he doesn't want change status quo changed by force in N. Korea